|
Criteria |
Advanced |
Proficient |
Basic |
Needs Work |
- clear thesis
- intro./organization/conclusion
- proper tone & english
- conventions
|
- clear thesis
- well organized
- no mistakes
- clearly communicated ideas
|
- might have some english mistakes
- does not impede understanding
|
- some mechanchanical errors
- not as well organized
|
|
|
|
- well written
- persuasive
- logical arguments
- at least 3 arguments
|
- 3 arguments
- may not be as clearly argued
- no logical errors
|
- 3 arguments
- poorly discussed & analyzed
- some errors in logical thinking which detracts from argument
|
- less than 3 arguments
- poorly organized
|
- use of support materials, cases & facts
|
- sufficient, relevant, supporting materials
- more than minimum (3)
|
- more than 3 sources
- relevant
|
|
|
- rebuttal of opposing point of view
|
- states opposing point of view clearly and effictively
- refutes main arguments (3)
|
- recognizes opposing point of view
- may not articulate it as clearly
- refutes main arguments (2-3)
|
- states point of view
- some refutation
|
|